JAIC 1989, Volume 28, Number 1, Article 1 (pp. 01 to 18)
JAIC online
Journal of the American Institute for Conservation
JAIC 1989, Volume 28, Number 1, Article 1 (pp. 01 to 18)

DARKENING OF PAPER FOLLOWING EXPOSURE TO VISIBLE AND NEAR-ULTRAVIOLET RADIATION

S. B. Lee, J. Bogaard, & R. L. Feller



2 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION


2.1 Effect of Exposure Time

ESPECIALLY PREPARED WATER-LEAF (without size) test sheets based on four types of paper stock, designated GP (groundwood pulp), UBP (unbleached pulp), FP (filter paper) and BP (bleached pulp) (see Table I regarding symbols and description of the pulps) were exposed during an initial series of tests for 18.8, 37.5, 65.8, and 155 hours in the Atlas Electric Devices xenon-arc Fade-ometer¯ equipped with Pyrex¯ filters. The respective net exposed energy, monitored at 420 nm, was 250, 510, 904, and 2120 kJ/m2. Reflectance readings at 460 nm, taken from measurements of the spectrophotometric curves, were noted at various times on the samples during exposure in the Fade-ometer¯ and during a subsequent period of storage in the dark in a steel cabinet in a constant-temperature and constant-humidity room maintained at 23°C and 50% RH. Darkening or bleaching is expressed in terms of the Kubelka-Munk function for the ratio of absorption coefficient, K, to the scattering coefficient, S, where K/S = (1 − R)2/2R, and R is the decimal fraction reflectance at 460 nm of a stack of six sheets of the paper being tested, relative to a standard white of barium sulfate. Table II compares K/S values with percent reflectance; increased K/S indicates darkening.

TABLE I Characteristic of Paper Samples Used (Before Exposure to Light)

TABLE II Comparison of Reflectance Values with Kubelka-Munk K/S Function∗

Changes in the K/S values, Δ(K/S), are plotted against exposure and storage time in Figure 1 for the GP test sheets and in Figure 2 for the UBP, FP, and BP sheets. [The more commonly used expression, post-color number,8 would be 100 times this, based on measurements with a narrow-band-pass filter peaked at 457 nm. However, with the introduction of modern spectrophotometers, it has proved convenient for this laboratory to use the reflectance at 460 nm. The net change is practically the same whether the reflectance at a wavelength of 457 or 460 nm is used.]9

Fig. 1. Darkening of Test Sheets Expressed as Increase in K/S Values at 460 nm, Δ(K/S), of Groundwood Pulp (GP) During and Following Various Exposures in the Xenon-Arc Fade-ometer¯ (Pyrex¯ Glass Filters). Exposures Expressed in Terms of kJ/m2 at 420 nm. Subsequent Storage at Room Conditions as Described in Text.

Fig. 2. Changes in K/S Value, Δ(K/S), at 460 nm for Test Sheets Prepared with Unbleached Pulp (UBP), Filter Paper (FP) and Bleached Pulp (BP). Exposures 1, 2, 3, and 4 are the Same Conditions as in Figure 1. Note Differences in Vertical Scale.

Three papers employed in these experiments were low in lignin. These did not change in color as much as the test sheets made with the groundwood pulp (GP). This can be seen in the much smaller changes in K/S values, Δ(K/S), in Figure 2 as compared to Figure 1. Subsequent to exposure, the filter paper (FP) darkened least of all, as one might expect in the case of a high-alpha-cellulose pulp. The particular sample of unbleached pulp (UBP) used in these tests was rather dark colored in its initial state, perhaps caused by alkalinity in the pulping treatments. In a number of laboratory experiences with this pulp we have found that it tends to bleach, at least initially, when exposed to either near ultraviolet or visible radiation (Figure 2a). In the case of the bleached pulp (BP) sheets, the net change during exposure was very small (Figure 2c); nonetheless, the sheets darkened initially, then bleached.

Regardless of whether exposure in the Fade-ometer¯ had caused bleaching or darkening, all of the exposed samples subsequently darkened when stored in darkness in a laboratory cabinet at 50% RH and 23°C (which we shall designate as post-irradiation darkening).10

In our experience we have observed that test sheets containing significant amounts of lignin tend to darken when exposed to near-ultraviolet radiation and higher-than-normal temperatures. Thus, one observes that the groundwood pulp (GP) samples darkened extensively during exposure in the Fade-ometer¯ (Figure 1). Figure 3 suggests that the post-irradiation darkening [K/S90 days − K/Sinitial, Δ(K/S)] of the groundwood sheets was related to the amount of exposure. This relationship was not evident, however, in the case of the three papers that contained low levels of lignin. The slight degree of post-irradiation darkening of the UBP and BP samples [only one-tenth that of the groundwood pulp, GP, sheets when expressed as Δ(K/S)] was practically the same regardless of the irradiation dosage. Any trend in post-irradiation darkening in these papers relative to the amount of exposure would have been obscured by experimental errors owing to the small changes in reflectance that took place. The longest exposed sample of filter paper (FP) seemed to have darkened more than the other samples during storage; nonetheless, the net change in all test sheets of this paper was too small to permit a firm conclusion (Figure 2b). The almost negligible darkening of the filter paper correlates well with the small changes observed in the low-lignin examples, BP and UBP.

Fig. 3. Post-Irradiation Darkening [Increased Δ(K/S) at 460 nm] of Various Test Sheets as a Function of Exposure. Data from Figures 1 and 2.

On first inspection of the major differences in composition of the papers (Table II), it appears that the degree of post-irradiation darkening following exposure in the Fade-ometer¯ might be influenced by the content of hot-alkali-soluble (HAS) matter (a measure of the oxidized and low-molecular-weight fractions of the pulp) as well as the lignin content in the paper. In this sense, the post-irradiation darkening might be considered to exhibit characteristics that one could expect from thermal-aging tests carried out on papers that have different degrees of oxidation as traditionally represented by carbonyl-group content, a property commonly reflected in the measurement of copper number or hot 1%-alkali-soluble (HAS) matter. This is essentially the conclusion reached by MacMillan using chemically-oxidized cotton linters.7 This point of view will be further considered in a later section in which handsheets made from pulps derived from groundwood were prepared in which both lignin content and HAS matter were varied. Probably both lignin and HAS content have an influence on post-irradiation darkening, but in the experiments described here HAS matter had little or no effect.


2.2 Effect of Initial pH

Acidity greatly influences the thermally-induced deterioration of paper; how does acidity affect the post-irradiation darkening? Using handsheets prepared from two types of pulp (UBP, GP) and aged filter paper (A·FP, Whatman No. 42 filter paper thermally aged at 90°C and 50% RH for 150 hours), post-irradiation discoloration was tested as a function of initial acidity of the sheets having pH values from 3.2 to 10.2 as determined by cold-water extraction. Air-dried test sheets at different pH's were prepared by treating the sheets with various buffers or with calcium hydroxide solution (see Table III). “Daylight” fluorescent and BLB blacklight fluorescent lamps were used in order to observe the effects of both visible radiation (having a trace of near, ultraviolet) and near ultraviolet alone on samples, exposing them at a lower temperature than was the case with the tests carried out in the Fade-ometer¯ . The results of exposing and subsequently storing samples of the three papers having six different values of initial pH are shown in Figure 4. (Because the presentation of the data would be too crowded, not every paper treated with the buffers in Table III is presented in this figure.) The GP sheets and the aged filter paper (A·FP) that were on the acid side (treated with buffer solutions at low pH) tended to darken faster, not only during the period of exposure to visible or ultraviolet radiation but also during subsequent storage at room temperature in the dark (post-irradiation darkening) (Figures 4a and 4c). In contrast, sheets treated with an alkaline buffer generally were stabilized against darkening both during the initial exposure to visible and near-ultraviolet radiation as well as during the subsequent storage in the dark. Least protection by alkalinity was observed in the case of the GP samples. Thus, post-irradiation darkening took place in practically every instance, but tended to be minimized as the pH of the papers tended towards alkalinity.

Fig. 4. Initial Changes and Post-Irradiation Darkening [Δ(K/S) at 460 NM] of Various Test Sheets as a Function of Initial pH of Sheet Following Exposure to Daylight Fluorescent Lamps (DFL). Note Difference in Vertical Scale in c). The Black Points Refer to Sheets Cast from Water, Unbuffered.

TABLE III Buffer Solutions Used for Paper Treatment∗

The UBP sample, an initially dark-colored pulp, bleached during exposure to the “daylight” fluorescent lamps; the acid sheets bleached the least. During subsequent storage, the UBP sheets tended to darken, the extent likewise being a function of the pH. As seen in Figure 4b, the alkaline-buffered papers exhibited the least post-irradiation darkening; at pH 10.2 the sheet apparently continued to bleach. Much the same results were observed with the UBP sheets during and following exposure to BLB blacklight fluorescent lamps, which emit principally near-ultraviolet radiation.

The net post-irradiation change in the aged filter paper (A·FP) was an order of magnitude lower but tended to follow much the same trend (Figure 4c).

When the net change in K/S at 460 nm after 120 days' storage, Δ(K/S), taken from Figure 4, is plotted against initial pH in the paper, Figure 5a results. In the case of exposure to BLB blacklight fluorescent lamps (near ultraviolet), the same general behavior is seen (Figure 5b). Although there are deviations in the experimental results, a general trend is indicated; post-irradiation darkening tends to be markedly reduced when the alkalinity of the sheets is above pH 9 and the degree of darkening increases when the papers have acidities greater than about pH 5. When one considers that pH is a function of the logarithm of the acidity or alkalinity, it is perhaps not unexpected that the accelerating effects at low pH would sharply curve upward and the minimizing effects of alkalinity would curve sharply downward in the linear plot of Figure 5. In the case of paper that contained little lignin, A·FP, acidity and alkalinity had scarcely any effect on the post-irradiation darkening. Again, one observes that the general level of darkening of the three types of paper, in the near-neutral condition, is in the order of the lignin content.

Fig. 5. Post-Irradiation Darkening [Represented by the Change in K/S, Δ(K/S), at 460 nm] After 120 Days' Storage as a Function of the Initial pH of Various Test Sheets Exposed to Daylight or BLB Blacklight Fluorescent Lamps: Groundwood Pulp (GP), Unbleached Pulp (UBP) and Aged Filter Paper (A·FP)

These results are simply technical observations regarding what happens to the papers having these values of pH when they are exposed to visible and near-ultraviolet radiation while on exhibition and are not at this stage intended to suggest changes in conservation-treatment procedures.


2.3 Effect of Gamma Cellulose Content

Bulk material was subjected to a short period of chloriting to remove much of the original lignin content from the unbleached pulp (UBP) (about 4% initially, diminished by this treatment to less than 1%). Caustic extraction at different strengths of alkali solution was then employed to reduce the level of gamma cellulose in individual samples. The composition of the resultant pulps is reported in Table IV; previous experiments using these same pulps have been described elsewhere.14

TABLE IV Characterization ofr Caustic-Extracted Pulps Prepared from UBP Stock

The post-irradiation effect on handsheets made from the different alkali-extracted UBP samples was investigated following exposure to the near-ultraviolet radiation from BLB blacklight fluorescent lamps. Exposures were carried out in the constant-temperature and -humidity room at 23°C and 50% RH for 19 days. Near-ultraviolet was used because it was considered that this radiation would provide a more severe exposure than daylight fluorescent lamps and therefore would enhance any detrimental effects of exposure that might be observed.

The changes in K/S values at 460 nm that occurred during exposure to the BLB lamps and during subsequent storage at room temperature of 23°C and 50% RH are shown in Figure 6. During the short exposure of about 30 hours to the near-ultraviolet radiation of the BLB blacklamps, all samples rapidly, although slightly, darkened. Thereafter during the period of exposure, samples that had been extracted with alkali, which had low gamma cellulose content (8.8% or lower), tended to bleach, returning essentially to the K/S values at 460 nm that they had before exposure. The original sample of UBP (unextracted) also bleached extensively and, during storage, did not darken sufficiently in 90 days to return to its original K/S value.

Fig. 6. Initial Changes and Post-Irradiation Darkening of Unbleached Pulp Sheets Alkali-Extracted to Achieve Decreasing Levels of Gamma Cellulose Content. Note Expanded Vertical Scale; the Changes are Small.

Note that the very small change observed in these tests (the right-side curves in Figure 6) exhibited almost the same rate of post-irradiation darkening irrespective of the composition of the extracted papers or the extent of the bleaching that had taken place under the BLB lamps. The test sheets contained little lignin; the percentage probably was no more than 1%. Little net darkening occurred during 90 days of storage; Δ(K/S) for the three extracted papers was about 0.0038 (increased darkening) in this time, whereas sheets of the unextracted pulp increased only slightly more, to the extent of 0.0058, perhaps because these sheets had the slightly higher content of lignin.

The results demonstrate, once again, that the post-irradiation tendency to darken, measured at 460 nm, is largely independent of the bleaching or darkening effects that may have occurred during exposure.


2.4 Effect of Lignin Content and Initial Hot-1%-Alkali-Soluble (HAS) Matter

As a final experiment, a variety of pulp samples were prepared from the groundwood pulp stock (GP) to allow the content of lignin and HAS matter to be varied as the result of a chloriting treatment followed by hot-1%-alkali extraction and by extraction with 17.5% sodium hydroxide solution. To minimize the possible effects of unintended oxidation of the cellulose, all samples were reduced with sodium borohydride prior to exposure. The values of initial lignin content and initial HAS matter in these samples are noted in Figure 7 where NC stands for not-chlorite-treated (the treatment to remove lignin); 1HC, 2HC, and 4HC are pulp stocks chlorite-treated for 1, 2, and 4 hours.

Fig. 7. Initial and Post-Irradiation Darkening of Pulps Prepared at Various Levels of Lignin and Hot-Alkali-Soluble (HAS) Matter. Effects of Exposure to BLB Blacklight Fluorescent Lamps.

Twelve test sheets made from pulps thus variously prepared were exposed under the BLB lamps for 400 hours and then left in the dark at a room temperature of 23°C, 50% RH for up to 90 days to check post-irradiation darkening. It is clearly seen in Figure 8 that the post-irradiation darkening of these pulps is related to lignin content. This supports the general conclusion indicated by the Fade-ometer¯ exposures shown in Figure 1 versus Figure 2. When the results are compared to the initial content of HAS matter, in Figure 9, there is no indication that HAS content plays a major role in post-irradiation darkening.

Fig. 8. Post-Irradiation Darkening of Test Sheets After 90 Days' Storage as a Function of Lignin Content (Summary of Data from Fig. 7).

Fig. 9. Post-Irradiation Darkening After 90 Days' Storage of Test Sheets Plotted as a Function of Hot-Alkali-Soluble (HAS) Matter (Summary of Data from Fig. 7). Arrows Indicate Sequence of Samples in Order of Chloriting Treatment (to Remove Lignin). No Positive Correlation Between HAS Matter and Post-Irradiation Darkening is Indicated.


Copyright © 1989 American Institute for Conservation of Historic and Artistic Works