JAIC 1999, Volume 38, Number 2, Article 3 (pp. 144 to 161)
JAIC online
Journal of the American Institute for Conservation
JAIC 1999, Volume 38, Number 2, Article 3 (pp. 144 to 161)

THE RESTORATION OF THE EARLY ITALIAN “PRIMITIVES” DURING THE 20TH CENTURY: VALUING ART AND ITS CONSEQUENCES

CATHLEEN HOENIGER



NOTES

. It is important to mention that The Yale University Art Museum is currently engaged in a collaborative project with the J. Paul Getty Museum to rehabilitate as many of the early Italian paintings at Yale as possible. This exciting project was initiated by the Yale conservators Mark Aronson, Patricia Garland, Joachim Pissarro and Joanna Weber, who are carrying out the new treatments at the Getty in conjunction with the Getty conservators Gene Karraker, Mark Leonard, Elisabeth Mention, Andrea Rothe, and Yvonne Szafran. Carl Brandon Strehlke of the Philadelphia Museum of Art is providing advice on which paintings should be prioritized. The dramatic results of this project are already visible in the galleries at Yale.



REFERENCES

Baldini, U.1978–81. Teoria del restauro e unità di metodologia. 2 vols. Florence: Nardini. 1:186.

Baxandall, M.1972. Painting and experience in fifteenth century Italy: A primer in the social history of pictorial style. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Belting, H.1994. Likeness and presence: A history of the image before the era of art. Trans. E. Jephcott. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. 459.

Bergeon, S.1990. Science et patience ou la restauration des peintures. Paris: Editions de la Réunion des musées nationaux. 230–31, 254.

Bomford, D., et al. 1990. Art in the making: Italian painting before 1400. London: National Gallery Publications. 50, 51, 89.

Brandi, C.1953. Il restauro dell'opera d'arte secondo l'istanza estetica o dell'artisticà. Bollettino dell'Istituto Centrale del Restauro13:1–8.

Brandi, C.1963. Il trattamento delle lacune e la Gestalt psycologie. In Problems of the 19th and 20th centuries: Studies in Western art, vol. 4. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press. 146–51.

Brandi, C.. [1963] 1977. Teoria del Restauro. Torino: Einaudi.

Brink, J.1979–80. Simone Martini's St. Catherine of Alexandria: An Orvietan altarpiece and the mystical theology of St. Bonaventure. National Gallery of Canada, Annual Bulletin3:37–56.

Carli, E.1960. Ein Neuer Simone Martini. Pantheon18:165–71.

Chelazzi Dini, G.1985. In Simone Martini e “chompagni.”Florence: Centro Di.

Christiansen, K., et al. 1985. Liechtenstein: The princely collections. New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art. 189–91.

Cole, B.1976. Giotto and Florentine painting, 1280–1375. New York: Harper & Row. 98.

Connelly, F. S.1995. The sleep of reason: Primitivism in modern European art and aesthetics, 1725–1907. University Park, Pa.: Pennsylvania State University Press. 2–22.

Conti, A. [1973] 1988. Storia del restauro e della conservazione delle opere d'arte. Milan: Electa.

Contini, G., and M. C.Gozzoli. 1970. L'opera completa di Simone Martini. Milan: Rizzoli Editore.

Corrie, R. W.1990. The political meaning of Coppo di Marcovaldo's Madonna and Child in Siena. Gesta29:61–75.

Davies, M.1961. The early Italian schools: National Gallery catalogues. 2d ed.London: National Gallery Publications.

deCastris, P. L.1989. Simone Martini: Catalogo completo dei dipinti. Florence: Cantini Editore. 86.

Dykstra, S. W.1996. The artist's intentions and the intentional fallacy in fine arts conservation. Journal of the American Institute for Conservation35:197–218.

Eastlake, C. [1857–58, printed 1867] 1988. Report of the director of the National Gallery. In M.Davies, The early Italian schools before 1400, rev. D. Gordon. London: National Gallery Publications. App. 1.

Elkins, J.1995. Art history and images that are not art. Art Bulletin77:553–71.

Fabbri, N. R., and N.Rutenburg. 1981. The tabernacle of Orsanmichele in context. Art Bulletin63:385–405.

Garrison, E. B.1972. Note on the survival of 13th-century panel paintings in Italy. Art Bulletin54:140.

Gombrich, E. [1966] 1971. Norm and form: The stylistic categories of art history and their origins in Renaissance ideals. In Norm and form: Studies in the art of the Renaissance. 2d ed.London and New York: Phaidon. 81–98.

Gordon, D., and A.Reeve. 1984. Three newly-acquired panels from the altarpiece for Santa Croce by Ugolino di Nerio. National Gallery Technical Bulletin8:36–52.

Hendy, P.1931. The Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum: Catalogue of the exhibited paintings and drawings. Boston: Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum. 240.

Hoeniger, C.1995. The renovation of paintings in Tuscany, 1250–1500. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press. 21–42, 151, 156.

Lowenthal, D. [1985] 1988. The past is a foreign country. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Minardi, T. [1864] 1987. Tommaso Minardi sulla qualità essenziali della pittura italiana dal suo risorgimento fino alla sua decadenza, extracted in19th-century theories of art, ed. and trans. J. C. Taylor. Berkeley: University of California Press. 176–94.

Neri Sciré, G., and F.Valcanover. 1985. Gallerie dell' Accademia di Venezia. Milan: Electa. 196.

Panofsky, E.1930. Das erste Blatt aus dem 'Libro' Giorgio Vasaris: Eine Studie über der Beurteilung der Gotik in der italienischen Renaissance mit einem Exkurs über zwei Fassadenprojekte Domenico Beccafumis. Städel-Jahrbuch6:25–72.

Phillips, D.1997. Exhibiting authenticity. Manchester and New York: Manchester University Press. 126–96.

Pope-Hennessy, J., with L. B.Kanter. 1987. The Robert Lehman Collection. New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art; Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press. 120.

Price, N. S., M. K.TalleyJr., and A. M.Vaccaro, eds.1996. Historical and philosophical issues in the conservation of cultural heritage. Los Angeles: Getty Conservation Institute.

Ruggles, A.1997. Personal communication. Painting Conservation, National Gallery of Canada, 380 Sussex Dr., Ottawa, Ontario K1N 9N4, Canada.

Scalia, F., and C.DeBenedictis. 1984. Il Museo Bardini a Firenze. 2 vols. Milan: Electa. 1:8, 13.

Schädler-Saub, U.1986. Theorie und Praxis der Restaurierung in Italien: Zur Entwicklung der Gemälderetusche von der Renaissance bis zur Gegenwart. Maltechnik-Restauro92:25–41.

Seymour, C., Jr.1970. Early Italian paintings in the Yale University Art Gallery. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press. 7.

Seymour, C., Jr., et al. 1972. Italian primitives: The case history of a collection and its conservation. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Art Gallery.

Smart, A.1978. The dawn of Italian painting, 1250–1400. Oxford: Oxford University Press; Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press.

Steegman, J. [1950] 1987. Consort of taste, reissued as Victorian taste: A study of the arts and architecture from 1830 to 1870. London: Century. 61–74, 250–51.

Stout, G. L.1941–42. Treatment of blemished paintings. Technical Studies in the Field of the Fine Arts10:99–112.

Stubblebine, J. H.1979. Duccio di Buoninsegna and his school. 2 vols. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press. 1:78.

vanMarle, R.1920. Simone Martini et les peintres de son école. Strasbourg: Heitz.

vanOs, H.1984. Sienese Altarpieces, 1215–1460, vol. 1. Groningen: Bouma's Boekhuis.

Vasari, G. [1550, 1568] 1878–85. Le vite de' più eccellenti pittori scultori ed architettori. Ed.G.Milanesi. 9 vols. Florence: G. C. Sansoni.

White, J.1979. Duccio: Tuscan art and the medieval workshop. London: Thames and Hudson.

Wölfflin, H. [1899, 1903] 1964. Classic art: An introduction to the Italian Renaissance. Trans. P. and L. Murray. 8th ed.London: Phaidon Press. 231–50.

Wood, J.1991. Perceptions of holiness in 13th-century Italian painting: Clare of Assisi. Art History14:301–28.


AUTHOR INFORMATION

CATHLEEN HOENIGER is associate professor of art history at Queen's University in Canada, where she teaches Italian medieval and Renaissance art as well as the crossover area between art history and art conservation. She has an M.A. in the history of science from the University of Toronto in 1983 and a Ph.D. in art history from Princeton University in 1989. Her dissertation is on the painting technique of Simone Martini, and she has published on this subject in Gesta and JAIC. She has also written on luxury silks in Venetian Trecento paintings for Electa, and on the techniques and conservation of wall paintings for The Dictionary of Art. Her book, The Renovation of Paintings in Tuscany, 1250–1500, examines the reworkings to a number of important early Italian paintings in relation to devotional and civic practices and questions the modern tendency to remove such “accretions” in search of the original. She is currently working on a broader study of art restoration and taste. Address: Queen's University, Department of Art, Kingston, Ontario, K7L 3N6, Canada.


Copyright © 1999 American Institute for Conservation of Historic and Artistic Works