WAACNewsletter
May 1999 Volume 21 Number 2


Letter to the Editor

Conservation Alert:
Landmark Murals Being Removed from Site-Specific Setting


We would like to bring to the attention of our membership a serious situation currently taking place in San Francisco. The monumental ensemble of site-specific murals by the Tonalist landscape painter Gottardo Piazonni, "The Land" and "The Sea" (1930-31), are being removed from San Francisco's Historic Old Main Library; both murals and library have National Landmark status. Significant interior and exterior architectural features are to be altered and demolished as well.

Despite repeated outcries from local, national, and international art and conservation organizations, and intensive preservation attempts at each point in the civic review process; action at the local level has been ineffectual in halting this destructive renovation to house the new Asian Art Museum. Removal of the murals by a team of conservators has already commenced. Current plans are to replace the murals with windows and move the murals to an as-yet-to-be-determined location elsewhere.

Time and local political options have expired. The removal of these murals and historic building features is of national consequence: that a prominent museum feels itself free to alter and remove cultural property sets a dangerous precedent. This situation challenges the fundamental precepts and ethics of our and other preservation and conservation organizations.

We would like to see all building renovations halted until conservation/preservation issues can be reviewed at a national level. We ask readers to contact colleagues in their respective and allied fields, and contact the members of their governing or executive boards to bring perspective and pressure to save these beautiful murals and their surroundings.

Thank you for whatever effort you are able to devote to this matter. We cannot underestimate the urgent need for your response at this time.

Respectfully submitted,

Theresa Andrews, Assoc. Conservator of Photographs/ Works on Paper, San Francisco Museum of Modern Art
James Bernstein, Conservator of Paintings, Private Practice, San Francisco
Lesley D. Bone, Objects Conservator, The Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco
Elisabeth Cornu, Head Conservator, Objects, Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco
Paula De Cristofaro, Paintings Conservator, San Francisco Museum of Modern Art
Carl Grimm, Head Paintings Conservator, The Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco
Molly Lambert, Architectural Conservator, Private Practice, San Francisco
Dawne Steele Pullman, Advanced Fellow, Paintings Conservation, San Francisco Museum of Modern Art
Patricia O'Regan, Assoc. Paintings Conservator, The Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco
Tony Rockwell, Assoc. Paintings Conservator, The Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco
Anne Rosenthal, Conservator of Paintings and Murals, Private Practice, San Rafael, CA
Charlotte Seifen, Third-Year Intern, Paintings Conservation, The Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco
J. William Shank, Chief Conservator, San Francisco Museum of Modern Art
Connie Silver, Conservator of Murals and Architectural Finishes, Private Practice, New York, NY

 [WAAC]  [WAAC Newsletter]  [WAAC Newsletter Contents]  [Search WAAC Newsletter]  [Disclaimer]


[Search all CoOL documents]


URL: http://cool.conservation-us.org/waac/wn/wn21/wn21-2/wn21-202.html
Timestamp: Thursday, 11-Dec-2008 13:02:35 PST
Retrieved: Saturday, 25-Nov-2017 00:12:39 GMT